idol thoughts

I didn't see all of idol last night so I don't know how good my opinion is today.  I thought all the performances I saw were pretty good.  I saw Scott, Matt, Allison, and Adam.  I've been thinking for a while that Scott is extremely talented but most of the talent is as a pianist not a singer.  Last night the first half of his song I was AMAZED by his voice.  But then came the second half, which was nowhere near as good.  I think he might be going home.  But I'd much rather see Lil go home - I have thought she was screaming her songs for way too long- she has a great voice but she isn't using it well at all.  Even in the little bit I saw at the end as they gave everyone's phone number, I thought she was screeching.  UGH!